What should colleges understand about how students have been learning AI before they reach us? On October 14, the FALCON community gathered from across Florida to explore that question with a panel from the recent Southwest Florida Symposium on AI in Education. Anna Haney-Withrow, Director of the Institute for Innovative and Emerging Technologies at Florida SouthWestern State College, moderated a conversation with Carrie Meyers, Director of Educational Workforce Talent for FSU INSPIRE, and Jim Reynolds, Director of STEM Outreach, both from Florida State University’s Learning Systems Institute. For background on the SWFL Symposium on AI in Education, see Anna’s earlier post.
Missed the meeting? Watch the recording or read on for a recap of the conversation.
Meeting students where they are
What should higher education understand about the AI experiences students are likely to have before they arrive on our campuses? And what are some of the constraints our K-12 partners are working with?
Carrie shared findings from three years of surveys with teachers in FSU INSPIRE’s professional learning programs, which have now reached more than 350 educators in Northwest Florida. Each year, more teachers report that they and their students are using AI, while awareness of district policy is still catching up. With limited time for direct instruction on AI in K-12 classrooms, students are largely learning on their own at home. A growing number of teachers are starting those conversations in class, and Carrie sees that as a promising place to build from.
Jim added that when teachers talk about AI, they usually mean chatbots, even though AI is already part of many of the assessment and adaptive learning tools they use every day. Many teachers are still at the beginning of their own hands-on experience with generative AI. With new policy requirements arriving in districts over the coming year, he expects a period of rapid development in how schools approach AI. For colleges, the takeaway is that students will arrive with a wide range of experiences, and many will have learned on their own.
A portrait of the AI-ready first-year student
If we imagined an AI-ready student at the end of one year in higher education, what knowledge, habits, judgments, and capabilities would we want to see in that student?
Carrie summed it up in two words: critical consumership. In her view, that means understanding how you learn best, weighing the environmental and economic impacts of AI, and engaging with it as a co-designer by writing your own prompts and staying active in the back-and-forth. She noted that AI has prompted educators to step back and think again about what good learning looks like. She also encouraged attention to metacognition, so students can recognize when a tool is supporting their thinking and when it is doing the thinking for them.
Jim described cognitive offloading as a human tendency that affects all of us, and compared it to how GPS has changed the way most of us navigate. As AI tools make each next step as easy as clicking a suggested prompt, he sees intentional planning and thoughtful engagement as essential habits for students and educators alike.
Carrie and Jim’s answers point to an opportunity for the first year of college. That year can move students from functional AI literacy, knowing how to use a tool, to critical literacy, knowing whether and when to use it. Familiar goals like critical thinking and metacognition remain at the center of this work. What’s new is defining how those skills look in practice when AI is part of the learning process, and building that into the first-year experience.
A shared responsibility
Where does responsibility lie in higher education? If we want an end-of-first-year student who has these capabilities, who’s teaching them that? Is it co-curricular? Is it curricular? How do we get it done?
Jim’s answer was “all hands on deck.” Because the tools change so quickly, no single office, course, or grade level can own this work. He emphasized helping students understand their own learning process earlier, along with a basic foundation in how AI tools work, how they’re trained, and why their outputs need to be evaluated. He drew a parallel to the early days of Wikipedia, when educators taught students to be critical consumers of a new source. The same approach applies today with new tools. He also stressed that educators across the K-16 continuum need support to build that foundational knowledge themselves.
Carrie pointed out that much of the AI training available to teachers today focuses on specific products. Broader training in how to think across any large language model would serve educators well. She noted that Florida’s new rule (6A-14.0719) requires parental opt-in for K-12, which means in practice that teachers who use AI will need to plan two versions of an activity, one with AI and one without. With teachers already stretched thin, some may decide AI activities aren’t worth the extra preparation, and for those who do, students in the same classroom may leave with very different experiences.
Carrie’s suggestion was to make AI part of the conversation at every grade level, which is possible to do without using an AI tool at all. For example, a science class can explore how machines learn, and a civics class can examine AI policy. That way, every student encounters AI in some form along the way.
Building genuine K-16 partnerships
Many of us in higher education would love to establish a collaborative conversation with our K-12 colleagues. How do we approach that relationship and avoid the pitfalls, where higher education comes in and says, “Here’s what you need to fix”? How do we have more genuine collaboration between our groups?
Jim’s advice was to lead with listening. Spend time in classrooms and hear directly from teachers about what they’re navigating day-to-day. Administrators are important partners, and teachers offer the clearest view of what’s happening with students. He suggested bringing together a small cohort of teachers from different grade levels and subject areas for an open conversation about where they see students heading and what K-12 and higher education can build together. Because AI will rarely come down to a simple yes or no, he encouraged everyone to get comfortable working in the gray areas, and to keep communication open as the tools continue to evolve.
Carrie added that strong work is happening in K-12, often in smaller pockets, and that teachers who have completed extended AI professional learning consistently ask for more. Her suggestion was to start by asking teachers what they need. She also issued a call to action for the FALCON community: partner on a statewide grant that connects higher education colleagues with local K-12 teachers to create and vet exemplary AI lessons across grade levels and subject areas. Teachers have told her the ideas are compelling, and seeing them work in a real classroom is what will help them move forward.
Looking ahead
The momentum from this conversation is a reminder that no sector has to solve this alone. Colleges and districts across Florida are building policies, frameworks, and partnerships at the same time, which creates a real opening to align around a shared picture of the AI-ready student. Carrie’s call for higher education and K-12 educators to collaborate on exemplary lessons is one promising direction, and the FALCON community includes many colleagues who may be well positioned to explore it. We hope these conversations continue across institutions and regions, and we look forward to learning from the work our members take on.
Resources from the chat:
- Florida Administrative Code Rule 6A-14.0719
- Profile of an AI-Ready Graduate (ISTE+ASCD)
- Transforming Teacher Preparation (ISTE)
- Four Cs for Emerging Adult Learners (Zoomers) in AI Learning Spaces (Online Learning Consortium)
- Critical Evaluation Frameworks for AI-Generated Content: The FLUF Test (UCF Teaching and Learning with AI)
- Florida K-12 AI Education Task Force (University of Florida)
- Demand for AI skills in entry-level jobs nearly triples since fall 2025 (NACE)
